[An edited version of this article appeared in the April, 2007 issue of LA Yoga and Ayurveda Magazine.]
If you’re thinking this must be a highly controversial topic, you’re right. On the one hand we have raw food enthusiasts recommending a natural diet of all raw food for everyone. This is based on the fact that raw food is high in nutrients, enzymes, and Prana (life energy). On the other hand, many Ayurvedic sources, including the Charak Samhita, recommend a diet of primarily cooked foods. This is because cooking increases the element of fire (agni), which is essential in the assimilation of nutrients and their transformation into the bodily tissues.
So how do we reconcile these two opposing
views? Is one correct and the other wrong? Which should we follow to
create and then maintain ideal health? If Ayurveda is the complete system
it claims to be, we should be able to apply its principles to any diet
or life philosophy and gain valuable insight in maximizing its benefits
and in creating balance.
Many of us, including myself, have experienced
the benefits of raw food and juices, including: increased energy, clarity
of mind, enthusiasm, radiant complexion, and weight loss, just to mention
a few. There are certainly many documented cases of individuals overcoming
serious health issues, some life threatening, thru adherence to a raw
food regime. Regardless of our philosophical leanings, we can’t deny
or dismiss such dramatic findings.
On the other hand, how do we account for individuals who have had less than favorable results by eating primarily raw uncooked foods?
Adverse symptoms may include abdominal bloating, gas, constipation, insomnia, etc. In practice, I have observed more than a few long time raw food enthusiasts develop imbalances and even serious conditions, such as: jaundice, liver dysfunction, emaciation, and neurological disturbances.
My recommendation for those who chose
to follow a raw food diet is to apply some of the ancient Ayurvedic
wisdom to help avoid potential problems and help you stay well. Ayurveda
recognizes our unique individual differences. There is not just one
dietary approach that would be ideal for everyone. In order to correctly
determine our optimal requirements we need to examine many factors.
We have to take into account the individuals constitution (Prakruti),
the nature of their imbalance and symptoms (Vikruti), the seasonal and
climatic influences, stage of life, occupation, etc.
My favorite example is: Are we looking
at a healthy 25 year old Pitta individual living in Hawaii in the summer,
working as a yoga teacher, or a 60 year old Vata individual, with a
Vata imbalance living in Alaska in the winter, working outdoors as a
construction worker? Obviously, even without an understanding of Ayurveda,
common sense would dictate that these individuals would require significantly
different diets to maintain homeostasis, balance, and optimal health.
In general, those of a Pitta, or Pitta/Kapha
Constitution, without a significant Vata imbalance can do very well
on some raw food in their diet, especially in the late Spring and Summer
Seasons. In fact, most if not all of the main raw food advocates do
have Pitta dominant in their constitution. The element of Fire in their
constitutions allows them to do well with a cooling diet. But if someone
has a severe vata imbalance, characterized by: excessive worry and anxiety,
sense of being overwhelmed, light-headed, spaced-out and not grounded,
dryness, abdominal gas, bloating, or constipation, they may need a diet
of nourishing, warm, moist, easily digestible cooked food as part of
their healing journey.
One of the primary reasons given for
consuming food in its natural raw state is that it is high in Prana.
Prana is usually defined as Life Energy, or Vital Life Force, but if
we research further, we find it is that and much more. The Prasna Upanishad
provides us greater insight as to the nature of this elusive substance.
It states that whatever exists in the universe, animate or inanimate
is dependent upon Prana. Within the body, Prana manifests as the five
forms of Vata: prana, udana, samana, vyana, and apana. Within the environment,
but external to our bodies, we find Prana consists of three qualities:
Soma (the cooling lunar influence), Agni (the heating Solar influence),
and Marut, the subtle vibrational influence from the space and air elements.
It is these qualities, and not the doshas themselves (vata, pitta, and
kapha), that exist within food. It is widely held that cooking food
destroys Prana, and transforms “live food” into “dead food”.
But, if Agni (fire) is one of the qualities of Prana, we perhaps need
to rethink this perspective.
I would suggest that overly cooking
food would diminish Prana. This is due to the high Agni burning and
thus reducing Soma. Also, cooking in a microwave oven, where the food
molecules are rapidly and violently exploding into one another, creating
friction, heat, and many damaging free radicals, should be avoided.
Cooking slowly, with fire (wood is the ideal, although gas is much more
convenient), is the Ayurvedic recommendation for maximizing the assimilation
of nutrients in our foods, allowing those nutrients to be transformed
into healthy tissue.
So, does that mean that cooking is the
only means of allowing Agni to help in the transformation of food into
tissue, and what about raw juices?
Raw juices, both fruit and vegetable provide the best of what raw food has to offer. They begin with real food, which is abundant in a vast array of nutrients: proteins, carbohydrates, essential fatty acids, vitamins, minerals,
and phytonutrients, not to mention who
knows how many yet undiscovered nutrients nature has abundantly provided
us. The real issue is in assimilating these nutrients so that they can
provide the optimum nutritional benefit to all the tissues of the body.
The outer layer of fruit and vegetable molecules is comprised largely
of cellulose. Since we lack the enzyme, cellulase, that breaks down
cellulose, we must either cook, juice, or chew until the food is liquefied.
Without cooking, the fire element is
reduced, and this has the potential to create imbalances due to the
overly cold, dry, light, or even heavy qualities found within raw foods.
So how can we minimize these effects and still maximize our ability
to create and maintain optimal health?
By using these simple Ayurvedic principles,
any diet can be made more balancing:
In addition, insuring each meal contains all six tastes: sweet, sour, salty, pungent, bitter and astringent, will further add not only to the nutritional value of what you’re eating, but will create a greater sense of wellbeing, satisfaction, and balance.
Mark L. Vinick, D.C.
drmark@drmarkvinick.com
1860 S. Elena Ave. Suite A
Redondo Beach, CA 90277
Office Tel: 310-375-HEAL (375-4325)